SMBHRPaychex cost review

What C-Level pays Paychex today.

From the November Paychex invoices you sent. Prepared for Scott Blackledge and Johnny-Lee Reinoso, November 17, 2026.

$7,140a year in Paychex fees
$595a month
$66per employee per month, for 9 employees
Where it goes

Four charges make up the $7,140.

Payroll runs every two weeks, so charges billed each payroll happen 26 times a year.

ChargeHow Paychex bills itPer monthPer year
PEO admin fee$176.13 each payroll, for all 9 employees together$19.57 per employee, per payroll$382$4,579
Workers' comp$20.03 each payrollThrough your PEO$43$521
Flex Time and time-off tracking$11.67 for each of 9 employees, plus $29Billed monthly by Paychex of New York$134$1,608
Protection Plus$4 for each of 9 employeesBilled monthly on the HR Services statement$36$432
Total$595$7,140
How we checked it

The November 13 payroll invoice, line by line.

The lines add up to exactly what Paychex debited from your account.

Line on the invoiceAmount
Wages$13,601.09
Employer Social Security and Medicare$1,040.46
Federal unemployment (FUTA)$2.50
State unemployment (SUI)$13.36
PEO benefits line$59.43
PEO workers' comp$20.03
PEO admin fee, 9 employees$176.13
Returned deductions-$505.84
Debited November 12$14,407.16
What we see

Your Paychex fees look fair. Medical is the open question.

  • The admin fee is low. About $42 per employee per month. The PEOs we quote for teams your size usually run about $80 to $125.
  • Workers' comp looks right. About $0.15 per $100 of payroll fits an office classification.
  • Flex Time tracks hours. With a mostly salaried team, it's worth asking whether you use it.
  • Medical is where savings usually are. It isn't on these invoices. Send the medical bill and we'll add it.

Not in the $7,140

Dental, vision and life premiums. The company's share was $140.46 on the November statement. That's insurance, not a Paychex fee.

The 401(k) fee, about 0.55% a year of plan assets ($6.43 in November), paid from employees' accounts.

Wages and payroll taxes.

Fees charged per employee move with headcount.